Psychology of the Pink Elephant Monster
The other day I was rummaging through the pantry at home andI noticed an old bottle of wine. I knew I wouldn’t ever drink it and threw itaway. My mother saw me do this and gave me the whole speech about how I wastethings that are still good. Ignoring her speech, because I heard it before, alight bulb had lit in my head. The situation reminded me of how I had interpreted the two articles we had to read this week.
First, I realized I was becoming the pink elephant in the wine industry as most people are in the fashion industry. I consume with the “denial of limits” to how it is affecting the world as well as fueling an industry. (Armstrong & LeHew, 2012). This denial came solely on the thought that this item I had purchased was meant for one purpose and one purpose only. I had bought the bottle of wine a few years ago for thanksgiving. After thanksgiving it had lost its special meaning and sat in the back of the pantry for over two years as just another bottle ofwine.
This can be a good metaphor for the fashion industry. We buy things for specific reasons; such as going to a wedding, thinking that even afterthe wedding we will surely wear them again. So after the wedding we put the item away and never use it again.
In my opinion this is mainly due to the turnaround of the fashion industry. We don’t wear things because they aren’t in “style” thisweek. This problem seems more prominent with women than men. I know a handful of women who buy things, wear them once, and then never wear them again. For example, one blonde that will stay nameless, said that one of the reasons she buys clothing and only wears them once is because “it’s not in style anymore.”
This turnaround was talked about in the article “FashioningSustainability” as one of the reasons why the clothing industry is considered unsustainable. They stated that “the fast fashion turnaround means that clothing has become more disposable.” I believe this is another reason we use clothing items once. We think that because something new has come out we should just forget about what we bought last week and purchase the new thing.
A possible remedy of this fashion turnaround was mentionedin the article written by Armstrong and LeHew. This concept is called slowdesign.
“Slow design implies that the design is no longer controlledby time, which eliminates the need for constant updates and production to compete in the marketplace.”
Slowing down the rate that clothing is presented to the public may reduce the amount people purchase. It may also force people to wear items of clothing more thanonce due to a limited amount of alternatives.
Another possible remedy would be to follow the ideas of modernists. When they designed products they used the principle, "form follows function." (Thorpe, 2007) They felt that the function is more important than the aesthetics of the products. This could also help slow down the turnaround if the purpose of clothing was more than one dimensional. If that outfit you bought for the wedding was appropriate for other events or even every day use.
Another possible remedy would be to follow the ideas of modernists. When they designed products they used the principle, "form follows function." (Thorpe, 2007) They felt that the function is more important than the aesthetics of the products. This could also help slow down the turnaround if the purpose of clothing was more than one dimensional. If that outfit you bought for the wedding was appropriate for other events or even every day use.
These may be a temporary answers to making the fashion industry sustainable but I don’t see them as being long-term solutions. On the poster I had posted on my blog last week, it said some of the factors that Industrial Designers take into account when designing completely sustainable products. As we all know the fashion industry has done great strides in increasing the technology used to create its items. This in turn saves time and energy. But what the fashion industry has not done is improve the user habits. It has instead created pink elephant monsters out of its clients. It has imprinted the importance of buying new things on our mind, and until we get over this disposable world mindset I don’t see the fashion industry ever beingable to be completely sustainable.
Questions
Does the sentimental gain of buying clothing outweigh thewaste your producing?
Is fashion “communism” a good solution for the industry?
Further Reading
After further research into this subject I found an article explaining a reason why women buy clothes, wear them only once, if at all, but don't throw them out. That reason was
because they feel guilty of wasting money. According to the article, "British women
waste £1.6 billion on clothes they never wear". (Poulter, 2011) This is
just another example of the mindset of people as consumers. I would think that
this guilty conscious would make them wear those clothes, but if they also had
the mindset of the clothing not being in style, then that may override the
guilty conscious.
First: For example, one blonde that will stay nameless, said that one of the reasons she buys clothing and only wears them once is because “it’s not in style anymore.” HAHA I think I know who this is.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion this is mainly due to the turnaround of the fashion industry. We don’t wear things because they aren’t in “style” this week. ---> The industry is not going to slow down. I think we should try and find a way to produce a blend of something to create a lower cost instead trying to control the rate that the fashion industry puts out new lines. but this goes for alot of industries, it happens in Interior Designers as well.
This issue is an issue within our nation, we have created a society that is all about what is new and hot. What about our world? It's old and fragile... A new fabric that is eco friendly that would have a large variety of application options is what I think needs to be discovered.
Hi, Cally;
DeleteThis is a very thoughtful comment. Try incorporating some of the readings into your post to boost the your contribution.
Ya I agree a new fabric needs to be discovered to increase its applications, such as maybe a fabric that doesn't show runs or seams and could be used over and over without getting damaged. That might be cool. Turn you evening dress into a work shirt then into something else, haha. Unfortunately I don't think that will help the industry cause it will be just another thing that is new and everyone will want it. Hopefully they will realize that it could be interchangeable and use it more than just once.
DeleteHi, Tanner;
ReplyDeleteI agree with Cally: Why should this blonde be able to retain her anonymity?! Ha ha!
You have done a nice job of synthesizing the readings from this week. You obviously understand this challenge, and this challenge is as applicable in interiors as it is for apparel. There is an interesting report out called Fashion Futures 2025 that gives some scenarios of different ways the globe may respond to this "fashion" challenge. One is, indeed, to slow everything down, increase quality, reduce quantity, etc. The other, is to speed things up, keeping the fashion pace, but increasing the efficiency and dispose-ability of products. We keep our fashion, without the toxic byproducts. Of these, which do you think might be most feasible in your field? Can you see a wallpaper-for-a week concept?!
You have some places in your blog where two words are "smooshed" together. I'm not sure if this is what Blogger did, but just make sure you break these up before posting next time.
Also, you seem to be missing results of the research activity? If you can revise by Tuesday, you will not be penalized. Thanks!
Dr. Armstrong,
DeleteYa for some reason when I uploaded the blog onto here it combined a lot of the words. I tried to go through it and fix it once someone told me but I never seemed to get them all, haha.
The Fashion Futures 2025 article seems interesting! I'll have to look into it.
Evening dress into a work shirt, cool idea. A repurposing shop maybe would be a good place to recycle the material and be able to buy something "new" but it would not be contributing to the production issues.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if they have a recycling clothes program in America? I'm sure the thought of using used fabrics isn't ideal but would be a good way to not waste them.
DeleteI agree completely with your statement in your further readings. Being someone who was once a shopaholic and a hoarder, I empathize with the feeling of buying things but having the inability to do anything with them over the pure guilt of wasting money. Not to mention I am a complete victim to clothing brands and and the fashion industry's turnaround. However, by educating myself with the harm that this habit does to myself and the environment around me, I've become more self-aware and have begun to get myself out of this vicious circle. My hope is that with more people researching, reading, and having an interest in sustainable design, then they too can get out this habit. If anything, it would be slightly beneficial if key industry people and certain brands that people obsess over would pick up on a few of these sustainability ideas.
ReplyDeleteTanner -
ReplyDeleteIntriguing article! When I finished reading it made me think of how ingrained the concept of fashion is into everyone, because I know I'm guilty of this! Do you think like mentioned in Fashioning Sustainability that retailers and brands have influence in the fashion world to a certain extent and could market eventually pushing its consumer into a different way of thinking that is more environmentally friendly?
I for sure think retailers and brands have influence in the fashion world. I know the brands want to sell their products to be a successful company, but I think the sheer amount of retail stores is one problem in the world. Maybe limiting the amount of retailers would help slow down the turnaround.
Delete